Observatorio de I+D+i UPM

Memorias de investigación
Communications at congresses:
Ethics and materials. Some Spanish Case Studies
Year:2013
Research Areas
  • Engineering,
  • Humanities
Information
Abstract
In Navea, north of Spain, a medieval arch bridge shows a visible distortion (fig.1a). A stone falls down from the web of a gothic vault in a big parish church in Burgos (fig. 1b), and a voussoir falls down from the rib of another gothic vault in Oviedo (fig. 1c). An oval dome collapses in Zaragoza, though another four identical domes remain safe (fig. 1d). Sometimes the building has to support new, heavier loads. The ruin of the abandoned (since the 19th Century) monastery of Melón should be consolidated, some vaults are rebuilt and the visitors can walk over them. A Franciscan Convent is going to be turned into a Cultural Centre, the loads to be supported being multiplied by a factor of two. A little medieval bridge is asked to support the pass of heavy lorries. These are some of the cases I have studied in the last two decades, all of them referring to questions of structural safety. These are the kind of situations which often occurs in the field of Historic Structures. They require a study and an answer. This is no scholarly work (though in some cases new lines of future research will emerge). A judgement must be made by the expert and this judgement affects the safety and economy, in the last instance, of people. As there are rarely unique answers, the behaviour of the expert, then, can also be judged as "ethical", if he proposes an intervention that is necessary and adequate (or, recommends no intervention, judging the situation safe), or "non-ethical", if recommends an unnecessary or disproportionate intervention. In relation to the monument, also, the proposal can be judged ethically; any intervention damaging seriously the character of the monument may be labelled un-ethical.
International
Si
Congress
Déontologie de la pierre. Stratégies d'intervention pour la cthédrale de Lausanne. Actes du colloque pluridisciplinaire des 14 et 15 juin 2012. (Monuments vaudois, hors-série 1)
960
Place
Lausanne
Reviewers
Si
ISBN/ISSN
978-2-8399-1138-2
Start Date
14/06/2012
End Date
15/06/2012
From page
95
To page
103
Déontologie de la pierre. Stratégies d'intervention pour la cthédrale de Lausanne. Actes du colloque pluridisciplinaire des 14 et 15 juin 2012. (Monuments vaudois, hors-série 1)
Participants
  • Autor: Santiago Huerta Fernandez (UPM)
Research Group, Departaments and Institutes related
  • Creador: Departamento: Estructuras de Edificación
S2i 2020 Observatorio de investigación @ UPM con la colaboración del Consejo Social UPM
Cofinanciación del MINECO en el marco del Programa INNCIDE 2011 (OTR-2011-0236)
Cofinanciación del MINECO en el marco del Programa INNPACTO (IPT-020000-2010-22)